HEBERLING LAB

Botanical look-alikes...on the other side of the world!
East Asia-Eastern North America are more similar than you might think.
 
This maple specimen was collected in August 1937 by J.R. Steck and R.J. Templeton in Pittsburgh’s Schenley Park. At first look, it is clearly a maple...its leaves have that “mapley” look!  But upon closer inspection, this specimen was collected from a planting. The species is from Japan – Honshū maple or grey-budded snake-bark maple (Acer rufinerve).

Now, check out this doppelgänger specimen, another maple collected by famed Carnegie Museum curator Otto Jennings in late August 1925 in Elk County, Pennsylvania. This similar looking species is found across Eastern North American forests – striped maple (Acer pensylvanicum).  Though you can’t tell from these leaves and stems, the bark also has distinctive striping (hence the name) that is uncannily like its Asian relative species above.
 
There are many species across Eastern North America and far away East Asia that look almost identical at first glance.  Why?  This observation has long been of interest to botanists for centuries, notably by Asa Gray at Harvard in the 1800s. Eastern North America and East Asia are comprised of many shared genera across continents, with species within remarkably similar!  These are called “disjunct” genera, resulting from a shared evolutionary history, with both floras once connected in geological time but have since been separated over many thousands of years. Interestingly, of the shared genera between regions, East Asia comprised roughly two times the number of species within compared to Eastern North America.  A lot of interesting evolutionary studies have been done on this disjunction across these floras, with many more to do!
 
Find these maple specimens and 3,030 more from across the world in the Carnegie Museum Herbarium here: https://midatlanticherbaria.org/portal/collections/list.php?db=328&includecult=1&taxa=Acer&usethes=1&taxontype=2
​

Autumn has fallen. (Fall has autumned?)
 
This specimen of red maple (Acer rubrum) was collected on November 13, 1915 by Otto Jennings near Finleyville, Pennsylvania (about 30 miles south of Pittsburgh).  Jennings was an influential botany curator (and biology professor at University of Pittsburgh and director of Carnegie Museum, among many other roles through his many decades career at the museum).
 
Just imagine how beautifully red these leaves must have been.   And you’ll have to imagine because this specimen is just twigs!
 
But upon closer look, the twigs have a lot to admire.  As with other deciduous trees in Pennsylvania, the buds are primed and ready.  In spring (as early as March for red maple!), these buds will swell and flowers will emerge.  Leaves will follow.  
 
But first, we wait it out through winter.  
 
Pay attention to tree buds this winter. They have a lot to say.
 
Find this red maple specimen here (along with 512 others!): https://midatlanticherbaria.org/portal/collections/list.php?db=328&taxa=acer+rubrum&usethes=1&taxontype=2

Spring goes on!

Spring seems to happen fast, which makes it all the more special and worth our attention. Comfort can be found in the new life of spring, a time of change.
 
Happy official first day of spring! For many people, spring conjures of sunshine (and rain), birds tweeting about, and plants emerging from winter. Trees flower and leaf out high up in the canopy. Wildflowers emerge below, many playing a delicate balance between getting injured by cold or frost but taking advantage of the longer sunny days before being shaded out by tree leaves.
 
Many deciduous trees flower before, during, or just after they produce a new spring flush of leaves. That’s right – trees flower too! Keep a careful look out for them now and over the coming month. Many trees flower early in the spring, with small clusters of flowers. These easy to overlook flowers 40 feet or more up in the canopy are easy to overlook.  They are often quite small and are wind pollinated. That means that rather than relying on insects, the wind blows their pollen, transferring it to female flowers. (And also...as many with allergies know, we breathe in pollen too...)  Upon fertilization, seeds begin to develop. Flowering early, before leaves are out, is adaptive because the flowers are not blocked by vegetation.
 
This specimen of silver maple (Acer saccharinum) is in flower, but leaves are not yet emerged. Silver maple is native to swampy, wet areas such as around lakes across eastern North America.  It is also planted, so it is now found in many habitats. It has beautiful bark that forms distinctive strips and with “maple-looking” leaves that are deeply loped.
 
Beyond the science, this specimen also tells an important cultural story about the history behind the Carnegie Museum.  This specimen was collected by Otto Jennings in Olena, Ohio in 1898.  Otto Jennings was one of the first curators of botany at the museum. This specimen was collected when he was only 20 years old, six years before he moved to the museum. He was born in 1877 on a farm in Olena, Ohio. He collected this specimen not far from his childhood home.  Jennings started his 60-year tenure at the Carnegie Museum six years later, in 1904. He made many contributions throughout his career, serving as the Curator of Botany, Director of Education, and eventually Director of the Carnegie Museum of Natural History.  He also was Professor of Head of the Department of Biological Sciences at the University of Pittsburgh, having advised many students.  His legacy remains to this day for his influence on the museum, botany, conservation, and environmental education.
 
So many stories behind these specimens.

Who needs leaves?
 
This red maple (Acer rubrum) specimen was collected on November 13, 1915 by former Carnegie Museum curator Otto Jennings on a rocky back north of Finleyville, Pennsylvania.
 
Something about herbarium specimens that are just branches, with no leaves or flowers.  But the flowers and leaves are there…well, sort of.  
 
Check out the nice buds on this specimen. Many deciduous tree species in temperate areas (like Pennsylvania) have “preformed” buds.  These buds are produced in the summer, packed with leave and/or flower tissue. You can see these buds swell during the winter in preparation for budburst.  Then when the conditions are right (like temperature and chilling time), the plant is ready to go! The cells don’t need to be made, and spring budburst is all about expansion.

It is fun to think of what is inside these buds.  There is a lot going on in there. Keep an eye on them on the trees in your neck of the woods. Many are rearing to go, riding out the winter.
 
Find this specimen and search for more here.

Well, that’s kinda weird!
These red maple (Acer rubrum) leaves were collected by Dorothy Pearth on November 6,  1959 at  Coles Summit in Huntingdon county, Pennsylvania. Dorothy Pearth (1914-1996) was a curator at the Carnegie Museum. She made two special notes on the label: “with exceptionally long petioles” and “many leaves with very long petioles.” (Petioles are the stalks that connects leaf to stem)
 
Herbarium data are often considered “biased.” All data collected haphazardly or by many different people across centuries with different intended purposes undoubtedly skew reality to some extent, depending on the research question.  It is rightfully something to consider when using specimens in research. Taxonomic bias (what species are collected), geographic bias (where specimens are collected – more often near roads, for example), temporal bias (high collection effort in some years), or collector bias (“that guy never collects grasses”) are just a few to consider. But just because “bias” may exist doesn’t mean it can’t be accounted for or the data are somehow useless.   Far from it!
 
In fact, bias can be a great thing! We want those “odd” specimens documented because they often tell us something important and new.  Maybe that specimen flowering in fall that normally flowers in summer is a sign of climate change.  Maybe that unfamiliar species is the first record of an introduced species that may  become invasive in the region.  Maybe that specimen that resembles species X, but has really huge leaves, is a new species  unknown to science!  Many undetermined specimens (that  is, those  that are identified to species)  are collected  for that very reason.  Many new species are first realized after someone  points out  that this specimen is “weird.” 
 
A recent paper in the American Journal of Botany (Pearson & Mast, 2019) surveyed collectors and search specimen records that include “outlier terms” – in other words, additional notes on the label written by the collector to point out something unusual about the specimen.  They found that this practice of pointing out outliers is an important route to detect early changes in the Anthropocene (the age of humanity).  Unusual specimens are important sentinels, bringing our attention to critical biological changes that may otherwise be overlooked in an era of rapid biological change.
 
Find this long-petioled red maple specimen online here: midatlanticherbaria.org/portal/collections/individual/index.php?occid=12233287&clid=0
​

“Autumn is a second spring when every leaf is a flower” – Albert Camus
 
It’s peak fall color in southwestern Pennsylvania, depending on who you ask!  This beautiful specimen of red maple (Acer rubrum) was collected on November 2, 2007 by Loree Speedy near Virgin Run Lake in Fayette county. It is unclear to me what exactly the “red” in red maple refers to specifically, or perhaps many parts of the plant (flowers, leaves, petioles).  One thing is for sure – it can have beautiful bright red foliage in the fall.  Also once called “swamp maple,” this species is widespread across eastern North America.  Due to altered effects on fire, wildlife management, climate, and other environmental changes, red maple is said to have increased in abundance over the past century.
 
Red colors can be the most striking of all fall colors…but my opinion changes!  This specimen shows great variation within the leaf, with reds and greens.  Each leaf have a certain uniqueness to them.
 
Red coloration in fall leaves results from the production of red pigments called anthocyanins. The pigments serve as a protectant, a sunscreen of sorts. You may also see young or stressed leaves turn red at other times of the year for similar reasons.  Other pigments like carotenoids (oranges) and xanthophyll (yellows) are present throughout the growing season, serving as accessory pigments for photosynthesis.  As chlorophyll breaks down and nutrients resorbed, these colors have their chance to shine.  Anthocyanins, however, are actively produced in fall.
 
Fall leaf coloration is complex, and not easy to predict. Many hues exist, even within a leaf (as shown in this specimen). Every species has different coloration. And, coloration differs within species based on a variety of factors.  Each leaf is unique and although short, fall is a great time to celebrate the beauty and science of leaves.
 
All of the red maple specimens in the mid-atlantic region from the Carnegie Museum herbarium are now imaged and available online: http://midatlanticherbaria.org/portal/collections/list.php?db=328&hasimages=1&taxa=Acer+rubrum&usethes=1&taxontype=2 

Black maple (Acer saccharum ssp. nigrum) collected by Herbert W. Graham on January 15 , 1927 along Big Sewickley Creek, just outside of Pittsburgh.  Black maple is sometimes considered is own species (Acer nigrum), depending on who you ask.

Who doesn't love a good herbarium specimen of sticks collected in winter?  We have quite a few specimens collected in Pennsylvania during winter when the species is leafless.  It is unclear exactly why they were collected in every instance, but it was likely for reference material to help with species identification in winter.  The downside is that specimens without leaves and/or reproductive structures can be difficult to definitively identify.  But what specimen is "perfect" anyway?

​We don’t always think of trees when we think spring wildflowers. But trees can have flowers too.  Many trees flower in early spring, before leafing out. Many of these flowers are small and inconspicuous, and wind pollinated. This specimen of sugar maple (Acer saccharum) was collected in April 1898 in Olena, Ohio. This specimen was collected by Otto Jennings, one of the first botany curators at the Carnegie Museum.  But this specimen is especially cool because it was one of his first collections, collected in his hometown, years before he became curator.
 
Jennings (1877-1964) was born on a farm in Olena, Ohio.  He collected this species in Olena when he was 21 years old, the year he started as a student at the Ohio State University.  Jennings started his 60-year tenure at the Carnegie Museum six years later, in 1904. He made many contributions throughout his career, serving as the Curator of Botany, Director of Education, and eventually Director of the Carnegie Museum of Natural History.  He also was Professor of Head of the Department of Biological Sciences at the University of Pittsburgh, having advised many students.  His legacy remains to this day for his influence on the museum, botany, conservation, and environmental education.

Spring leaf out is a bit “behind” in Pittsburgh this year.  Well, for Norway maple in Schenley Park compared to 1948.  Plant leaf out and flowering times is variable for many species each year due to differences in spring temperatures. This Norway maple specimen was collected by Botany curator Otto Jennings.  Norway maple (Acer platanoides) is commonly planted across our region, common as a street tree or park plantings.  Norway maple is invasive in Pennsylvania, spreading into natural habitats. Its leaves superficially resemble the well known sugar maple but has a different leaf shape. Norway maple has even been put on the Canadian 20 dollar bill instead of the native sugar maple (http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/canada-s-new-20-bill-at-centre-of-maple-leaf-flap-1.1343767). A good way to tell it is Norway maple is that exudes a white latex from the leaf when picked.

Keep an eye out for Norway maple over the next week!  That light yellow/green you see at the tips of trees (especially along highways) in early spring is not tree leaves, but flowers. And many of these trees in urban areas around Pittsburgh are Norway maple.  Many trees flower early in the spring, before they leaf out.  Many tree species are primarily wind pollinated, so flowering before most species leaf out facilitates pollen to blow around with fewer obstructions.
 
In a long-term project initiated last year, we are recollecting specimens on the same calendar date and in the same location as historic specimens in the herbarium.  These recollections will grow the herbarium with future use in mind – permitting comparisons across time, such as changes in leaf out dates, flowering, and genetic works.  Long term studies (and herbarium specimens) are important to understand the effects of climate change and other human activities because of yearly variation.  Check back for more on this project!
 
Image below: Norway maple buds today on a tree in Schenley Park, Pittsburgh (Apr 4, 2018).  It is not quite ready to go. Note the buds are swollen but are not yet burst.  Compare this to the specimen collected in 1948, in full flower and early stages of leaf expansion.

​Over 90 years old and still beautiful color!  This red maple specimen was collected on October 23, 1926 by Otto Jennings during a field trip of the Botanical Society of Western PA to Chestnut Ridge in the beautiful Laurel Highlands of Pennsylvania.  Red maple (Acer rubrum) is one of the most common trees in eastern North America.  You can find it from southern Canada down to Florida and Minnesota down to eastern Texas. And it is renowned for its beautiful scarlet red foliage in autumn.  Happy fall!